www.paywallnews.com Only News Behind Paywalls
New York Times / News - Politics

How Republican Lawmakers Responded to Trump’s Vulgar Immigration Remarks

Reports of the president’s comments prompted outcry from some lawmakers, but they were followed by notable silence from others.


Reports that President Trump referred to African nations as “shithole countries” and disparaged Haitians during an immigration meeting on Thursday prompted outcry from some lawmakers, but his comments were followed by notable silence from others. Here’s how Republicans in the House leadership, the Senate and other lawmakers who attended the meeting have responded:

Denounced the President’s Comments

Some lawmakers specifically criticized the president, while others countered the sentiment of his remarks.

Senator Lamar AlexanderTenn.

“We should respect every country, and for countries such as those in Africa where they have been less fortunate because of poverty or disease—some of the proudest moments of the United States have been when we have taken our wealth and our expertise and helped them.”

Senator Roy BluntMo.

“It’s clearly an unacceptable thing to say. You can’t determine what somebody is thinking or why they say what they say, but it’s an unacceptable view of the world and it’s an unacceptable thing to say.” »

Senator John BoozmanArk.

“Our country is made of immigrants. This diversity is what makes our country great and something all citizens should be proud of. No matter where people come from, they all deserve dignity and respect.”

Senator Susan CollinsMaine

“These comments are highly inappropriate and out of bounds and could hurt efforts for a bipartisan immigration agreement. The president should not denigrate other countries.” »

Senator John CornynTex.

“Unfortunately, I don’t know what was actually said yesterday. I certainly would not have said what was reported if that’s in fact true.”

Senator Jeff FlakeAriz.

“The words used by the president, as related to me directly following the meeting by those in attendance, were not ‘tough,’ they were abhorrent and repulsive.” »

Senator Cory GardnerColo.

“I’m not going to get into the who said, what said, but what was reported is unacceptable. But what we have to do is not let that define this moment. ”

Senator Lindsey GrahamS.C.AT THE MEETING

“Following comments by the president, I said my piece directly to him yesterday. The president and all those attending the meeting know what I said and how I feel. I’ve always believed that America is an idea, not defined by its people but by its ideals.” »

Senator Charles E. GrassleyIowa

“I think it detracts from the very important issue we got to get solved by March the 5th," the deadline for Congress to find a fix for the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, or DACA, which Mr. Trump is ending. "Bottom line, all people ought to be treated with respect.” »

Senator Orrin G. HatchUtah

“I look forward to getting a more detailed explanation regarding the president’s comments. Part of what makes America so special is that we welcome the best and brightest in the world, regardless of their country of origin.” »

Senator Johnny IsaksonGa.

“I did not hear it, but if it’s true, he owes the people of Haiti and all mankind an apology. That is not the kind of statement the leader of the free world ought to make, and he ought to be ashamed of himself. If he did not make it, he needs to corroborate the fact and prove it and then move forward.” »

Senator Ron JohnsonWis.

“Totally inappropriate and he should apologize. When you enter the public realm, I don’t care what your past was, I don’t know what kind of salty language you might have used, you stop doing it. You have a certain responsibility, a certain decorum that you need to conduct yourself in public with. You have children watching. You have nations watching.” »

Senator James LankfordOkla.

“If these comments are accurate, they are disappointing. I would not talk about nations like this, because the people of those countries are made in the image of God and have worth and human dignity. The United States should lead the world in respect for all people.”

Senator Mike LeeUtah

“The comments attributed to the president are insulting and distracting.”

Senator John McCainAriz.

“People have come to this country from everywhere, and people from everywhere have made America great. Our immigration policy should reflect that truth, and our elected officials, including our president, should respect it.” »

Senator Lisa MurkowskiAlaska

“What the president said is offensive and doesn’t reflect who we are as a country. It is particularly offensive just days ahead of our recognition of Dr. Martin Luther King. I am disappointed and suggest we move quickly to resolve the status of the Dreamers in a way that truly reflects our values.” »

Senator Rob PortmanOhio

“I wasn’t there, but if he said those things, it’s wrong and indefensible.”

Senator Pat RobertsKan.

“Allegedly it’s an off-hand remark, but even that, it’s most unfortunate. I try to stick to my business, committees, and get us a good farm bill. I’ve worked with the president. He’s been very personable. That kind of language wasn’t used. So I regret it.” »

Senator Marco RubioFla.

“We should evaluate immigrants based on who they are and not on the problems that exist in the nation of their birth. For example, for decades the people of El Salvador and Haiti have suffered as a result of bad leaders, rampant crime and natural disasters.” »

Senator Tim ScottS.C.

“If these comments are the president’s words, they are disappointing to say the least. The American family was born from immigrants fleeing persecution and poverty and searching for a better future. Our strength lies in our diversity, including those who came here from Africa, the Caribbean and every other corner of the world.”

Senator Patrick J. ToomeyPa.

“I hope the president retracts the suggestion, attributed to him yesterday, that America should not want immigrants from countries which he was accused of describing disparagingly. There are great people — many of whom would make great Americans — in every country on the face of the earth.”

House Speaker Paul D. RyanWis.

“So, first thing that came to my mind was very unfortunate, unhelpful.”

“I think it’s a big part of our strength, whether you’re coming from Haiti — we’ve got great friends from Africa in Janesville who are doctors who are just incredible citizens. And I just think it’s important that we celebrate that.”

Sidestepped or Did Not Denounce the President’s Comments

A handful of Republican lawmakers either sidestepped the controversy or did not directly denounce the president’s comments. Others disputed whether Mr. Trump made the vulgar remark at all, creating differing accounts from inside the room.

Senator Bill CassidyLa.

“Whether he said it or not, that’s not the issue. What about the higher problem of what do we do about border security and DACA?” »

Senator Ted CruzTex.

“I don’t know what was said and what wasn’t said. I can tell you the approach that I’ve tried to take in Washington is to stay out of the nastiness and the attacks and the ‘he said, she said,’ and the insults, and try to focus on substance, try to focus on results, delivering results.” »

Senator Rand PaulKy.

“I think it’s unfair to sort of draw conclusions from a remark that I think wasn’t constructive is the least we can say, and I think it’s unfair then to all of the sudden, paint him, ‘Oh, well, he's a racist.’ ”

Senator David PerdueGa.AT THE MEETING

“I’m telling you he did not use that word, George, and I’m telling you it’s a gross misrepresentation,” he said, responding to George Stephanopoulos of ABC News.

In a joint statement, Mr. Perdue and Senator Tom Cotton of Arkansas had previously said, “We do not recall the president saying these comments specifically.” »

Senator Tom CottonArk.AT THE MEETING

“I did not hear derogatory comments about individuals or persons, no.” »

Representative Mario Diaz-BalartFla.AT THE MEETING

“There are almost 800,000 young DACA beneficiaries who will face imminent deportation in March if we do not reach a deal. I will not be diverted from all possible efforts to continue negotiating to stop the deportations.” »

No Known Public Statements

The remaining Republican senators and key House members have made no known public statements responding to the comments. The New York Times has reached out to each of their offices.

Senator John BarrassoWyo.

Senator Richard M. BurrN.C.

Senator Shelley Moore CapitoW.Va.

Senator Thad CochranMiss.

Senator Bob CorkerTenn.

Senator Michael D. CrapoIdaho

Senator Steve DainesMont.

Senator Michael B. EnziWyo.

Senator Joni ErnstIowa

Senator Deb FischerNeb.

Senator Dean HellerNev.

Senator John HoevenN.D.

Senator James M. InhofeOkla.

Senator John KennedyLa.

Senator Mitch McConnellKy.

Senator Jerry MoranKan.

Senator James E. RischIdaho

Senator Michael RoundsS.D.

Senator Ben SasseNeb.

Senator Richard C. ShelbyAla.

Senator Dan SullivanAlaska

Senator John ThuneS.D.

Senator Thom TillisN.C.

Senator Roger WickerMiss.

Senator Todd YoungInd.

Representative Robert W. GoodlatteVa.AT THE MEETING

House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthyCalif.AT THE MEETING

House Majority Whip Steve ScaliseLa.

    ADS